Case Study 1: ANZ Processing Errors
The first case study includes numerous errors found in processing carried out by ANZ with respect to home loans as of 2003. From Ms Sarah Stubbings, the evidence was heard by the Commission. Along with this, the Head of Product of Home Loans by ANZ, New Zealand and Australia were also responsible for this.
Five categories related to errors of processing were established by this evidence by ANZ with respect to products of home loan as of 2003. Initially, in the time span of 2006 and the middle of 2013, some customers of ANZ were charged with a rate of interest higher than the usual as per the terms and conditions of the accounts. During the time span of 2003 and the end of 2012, some of these offset accounts were not linked properly to home loans. As a result, customers began to be charged with excessive interest (Kang et al. 2011). As the ‘Item 137 issues’, these problems were referred to collectively. Fixes with respect to these problems were carried out progressively from the end of the first quarter in 2012 to the first half of 2013. Secondly, in the time span of July 2013 to July 2017, some particular customers who had chosen a specific package of home loan following a drawdown or had been linked to an already existing home loan to a totally new package of a home loan were provided with the advantages of being connected to an offset account. This was referred to as the “Issue of Item 138” (Kang et al. 2010).
Some specific remediation programs were accepted by ANZ as it took a while for completion. Alongside this, it was also inconsistent due to expectations from the community. With respect to this, it’s remediation must be referred by ANZ with respect to the issues of Item 137, and perhaps with issues of Item 138 and 151. With respect to its submission, and perhaps to Item issues 138 and 151, ANZ had to refer its remedies. During its submission, ANZ made a statement that the delays in the remediation of Item 137 took place as a result of complex identification and calculation of the remediation of each customer. In addition to this, it was also not a result of any misconduct to invest the appropriate amount of resources in proper fixation of these errors. Furthermore, ANZ also stated that it embarked on a remediation program at that time. However, the company had not carried out a remediation of that complexity and magnitude earlier.
The second case study involves the consideration of car loans which have been approved by the auto finance business of Westpac via dealer intermediaries. The evidence was provided by Ms Nalini Thiruvangadam who a consumer is obtaining such a loan from Mr Phillip Godkin, the General Manager of Westpac and the organisation itself. During the time of proceedings, the loans which were provided by the auto finance of Westpac were sold under the names of Bank of Melbourne or St George. It has been acknowledged by Westpac that an overwhelming majority of these car loans were issued by the organisation and were a part of the initiative carried out by car dealers (Bonn & Fisher, 2015).
Case Study 2: Westpac Auto Loans
During the time of the proceedings, the organisation heavily relied on its dealers to carry out several different operations with respect to the responsible lending obligations of Westpac. In essence of this, the relationship of Westpac with its dealers can be summarised as the forging of an agreement carried out by its dealers. If they are carried out as per the terms and conditions, it would result in a loan that had been responsibly formulated. The data that was captured by the systems of Westpac and obtained by dealers was the primary source for the evidence of Westpac on whether or not reasonable inquisitions have been carried out. Alongside this, the management of communications by the dealer with the customer throughout the entire process of loan application is also to be taken into consideration.
The final case study showed the involvement of CBA in various lending practices with respect to the increase in credit card limit and credit cards. The evidence was provided by Mr David Harris who delivered a submission categorised as public, to the Commission along with Mr Clive Van Horen, who was the Executive General Manager of Retail Products. The credit card applications of CBA were carried out by filling a short, long or medium process for application. The process that is to be implemented relied upon the evaluation of the eligibility of the customer by the CBA by utilising data with respect to an existing consumer. A CBA consumer would only be considered to be eligible to utilise the short application form if, amongst other belongings, the deposition of salary took place on their behalf into an account of CBA.
The corporate governance has been associated traditionally with the issue of “principal-agent” or “agency”. The former type of relationship takes place when the owner of the organisation is not the same as that of the person who controls or manages it. For instance, financiers or investors hire agents or managers to carry out the operations of the organisation on their behalf. There is a need for managers on behalf of investors having specialised human capital for generation of returns with respect to their investments. Alongside this, managers may not require the funds of investors as they may not possess sufficient capital to invest of their own. In this regard, there is a clear segregation between the management of an organisation and financing. This implies that there is a distinct separation between control and ownership. Prior to looking at the relationship between firm performance and corporate governance alongside economic growth, it is necessary to possess a framework that can comprehend as to how the economic performance and firm governance can be influenced by corporate governance. One of the primary issues with the prolonged debate on corporate governance involves several different, yet conflicting perspectives on the nature and purpose of the organisation. This debate extends from positive problems concerning the operations of institutions to normative problems concerning the purpose of the organisation (Considine & Lewis, 2013). As a result, in order to formulate a conclusion to this debate, it is necessary to consider the various analytical approaches or backgrounds that are employed quite often. In several different contexts and ways, the term, corporate governance has been utilised. In accordance with this, the context of the subject varies widely.
Case Study 3: CBA Credit Cards
In the debate of economics concerning the influence of corporate governance on the performance, there are two different corporation models which are basically the stakeholder and shareholder model. In the narrowest aspects of the shareholder model, corporate governance generally encapsulates the formal accountability system of senior management to the shareholders. In a diverse sense, the model of stakeholders and corporate governance can be implemented to detail the network of informal and formal relations involving the association. Most recently, the approach of stakeholders highly emphasises on the contributions of stakeholders that can offer a long-term contribution with respect to the performance of the organisation (Collett & Hrasky, 2015). Along with shareholder value, the approach of shareholders also highlights the stakeholder ethics and business relations that have an influence on the reputation and long-term success of the organisation. As a result, there is a stark difference between these two models and as a result, a question related to emphasis evokes. The absence of a consensus with respect to the definition of governance of a corporation is reflected in the debate of reformation of governance as well.
Five classifications identified with mistakes of handling were set up by this proof by ANZ as for results of home credit starting at 2003. At first, in the time range of 2006 and the centre of 2013, a few clients of ANZ were accused of a rate of intrigue higher than the standard according to the terms and states of the records. Amid the time range of 2003 and the finish of 2012, a portion of these balance accounts was not connected legitimately to home advances. Subsequently, clients started to be accused of exorbitant intrigue. As the ‘Thing 137 issues’, these issues have alluded all in all. Fixes regarding these issues were done logically from the finish of the principal quarter in 2012 to the primary portion of 2013 (Lansley, Gibson & Fogarty, 2012). Also, in the time length of July 2013 to July 2017, some specific clients who had picked an explicit bundle of home credit following a drawdown or had been connected to an officially existing home advance to an absolutely new bundle of home advance were given the upsides of being associated with a counterbalance account. This has alluded as the “Issue of Item 138”.
Some explicit remediation programs were acknowledged by ANZ as it took temporarily for consummation. Close by this, it was additionally conflicting because of desires from the network. As for this present, it’s remediation must be alluded by ANZ as for the issues of Item 137, and maybe with issues of Item 138 and 151. Concerning its accommodation, and maybe to Item issues 138 and 151, ANZ needed to allude its cures. Amid its accommodation, ANZ created an impression that the deferrals in the remediation of Item 137 occurred because of intricacy distinguishing proof and count of the remediation of every client. What’s more, it was additionally not an aftereffect of any unfortunate behaviour to put a fitting measure of assets in the legitimate obsession of these blunders.
Models of Corporate Governance
There is a requirement for chiefs for financial specialists having particular human capital for an age of profits regarding their ventures. Close by this, directors may not require the assets of financial specialists as they may not have adequate funding to contribute of their own. In such a manner, there is a reasonable isolation between the administration of an association and financing. This suggests there is a particular partition among control and proprietorship. Preceding taking a gander at the connection between firm execution and corporate administration close by monetary development, it is important to have a system that can appreciate concerning how the financial execution and firm administration can be affected by corporate administration (Narracott & Bristow, 2011). One of the essential issues with the drawn-out discussion on corporate administration includes a few extraordinary, yet clashing points of view on nature and motivation behind the association. This discussion reaches out from positive issues concerning the tasks of foundations to standardizing issues concerning the reason for the association. Subsequently, so as to detail an end to this discussion, it is important to consider the different expository methodologies or foundations that are utilized frequently. The second contextual analysis includes the thought of vehicle credits which have been affirmed by the automobile fund business of Westpac by means of merchant middle people. The proof was given by Ms Nalini Thiruvangadam who is a shopper acquiring such a credit from Mr Phillip Godkin, the General Manager of Westpac and the association itself. Amid the season of procedures, the credits which were given by the car back of Westpac were sold under the names of Bank of Melbourne or St George. It has been recognized by Westpac that a larger part of these vehicle advances was issued by the association and was a piece of the activity completed via vehicle merchants (insurancebusinessmag.com, 2018).
Amid the season of the procedures, the association intensely depended on its merchants to do a few unique activities regarding the capable loaning commitments of Westpac. Fundamentally of this, the relationship of Westpac with its merchants can be condensed as the manufacturing of an assertion did by its merchants. On the off chance that they are completed according to the terms and conditions, it would result in a credit that had been dependably detailed. The information that was caught by the frameworks of Westpac and gotten by merchants was the essential hotspot for the proof of Westpac regardless of whether sensible examinations have been completed (Fleming, 2013). Close by this, the administration of interchanges by the merchant with the client all through the whole procedure of credit application is additionally to be thought about.
The last contextual investigation demonstrated the inclusion of CBA in different loaning rehearses as for the expansion in MasterCard limit and charge cards. The proof was given by Mr David Harris who conveyed an accommodation arranged as open, to the Commission alongside Mr Clive Van Horen, who was the Executive General Manager of Retail Products. The charge card utilization of CBA was done by filling a short, long or medium process for application. The procedure that will be executed depended upon the assessment of the qualification of the client by the CBA by using information concerning a current buyer. A CBA purchaser would just be viewed as qualified to use the short application shape if, among different effects, the statement of compensation occurred for their benefit into a record of CBA.
References
Fleming, G. (2013). Corporate governance in Australia. Agenda: A Journal of Policy Analysis and Reform, 5(2), 195-212.
Narracott, M., & Bristow, A. (2011). Corporate governance in Australia. International Financial Law Review, 35.(2), 521-652
Lansley, A., Gibson, B., & Fogarty, M. (2012). Corporate governance in Australia. International Financial Law Review, 3(3), 201-230
Kang, H., Cheng, M., & Gray, S. J. (2011). Corporate governance and board composition: Diversity and independence of Australian boards. Corporate Governance: An International Review, 15(2), 194-207.
Considine, M., & Lewis, J. M. (2013). Bureaucracy, network, or enterprise? Comparing models of governance in Australia, Britain, the Netherlands, and New Zealand. Public Administration Review, 63(2), 131-140.
Kang, H., Cheng, M., & Gray, S. J. (2010). Corporate governance and board composition: Diversity and independence of Australian boards. Corporate Governance: An International Review, 15(2), 194-207.
Collett, P., & Hrasky, S. (2015). Voluntary disclosure of corporate governance practices by listed Australian companies. Corporate Governance: An International Review, 13(2), 188-196.
Bonn, I., & Fisher, J. (2015). Corporate governance and business ethics: Insights from the strategic planning experience. Corporate Governance: An international review, 13(6), 730-738.
insurancebusinessmag.com (2018), Royal commission Interim report [Retrieved from https://www.insurancebusinessmag.com/au/news/technology/financial-services-royal-commission-interim-report-released-112496.aspx on Dec, 03, 2018]
Order an Essay Now & Get These Features For Free:
Turnitin Report
Formatting
Title Page
Citation
Outline
