Company Overview
Financial assessment of an organization can be done in appropriate manner through ratio analysis assessment as well as analyzing the performance of shares. Both of this information is considered by an investor while making investment decision relating to any organization. Present report revolves around assessment of Qantas Airways and Seek Limited in detail. Further ratio analysis of same has been done in order to assess liquidity, profitability and stability of both the companies.
Particular |
Qantas Airways Ltd. |
Seek Ltd |
Company Overview |
Qantas Airways is flag carrier of Australia having largest airline with fleet size along with international flights and global destinations. It is believed to be worlds third oldest airline subsequent to KLM and Avianca, it was set up in November 1920, started its international travelers flight in may 1935. The pet name of Qantas Airways is “Flying Kangaroo” (Annual Report of Qantas Airways, 2017). It is located in Sydney village of Mascot with its main centre at Sydney Airport. Word Qantas is derived from word “Qantas” which is acronym of its real name Queensland and Northern Territory. Qantas is founding member of Oneworldairline association. Since on march 2014 Qantas covers 65% share of Australia Domestic market and conceded 14.9% travelers travelling in and out of Australia. |
Seek Ltd is assorted group of companies which is comprised of united principle that is to assist people survive more satisfying and helpful working lives and facilitate association to be successful. It is listed at the Australian Securities Exchange having place within top 100 company appointing more than 6000 people as well as market capitalisation near to AU$6billion (Annual Report of Seek Ltd, 2017). The company is believed as universal leader in formation and functioning of online employment market. Seek builds optimistic contribution to people’s live by linking more people to related job prospects through its market scale and technology to create radically more effective more effective employment market. |
Products and Services |
The company is engaged in operations transportation of passengers and air shipments. Further it is evolved in operations of multiple subsidiaries comprising related business regarding vacations, travel operations and routed caterings (Annual Report of Qantas Airways, 2017). The main business relates to transportation of customer through application of two complimentary brands i.e. Qantas and Jetstar. Further the company also operation in special market i.e. Q catering. The Group’s widen portfolio of subsidiary comprises Qantas Freight Enterprises to Qantas Frequent Flyer. |
The company provides following services: · Online matching of employ and nominee with job prospects and associated services. · Online assignment and placement of applicants into position. · Making investment at initial phases of businesses and technologies that are in or contiguous to the core online employment market. · Allocation and provision of higher education courses. |
Alan Joyce |
Andrew R Bassat |
|
Salary of Chief executive officer |
3890000 |
$4538592 |
Statutory Profit and Loss (2017) |
$853 million |
$362.0 million |
Dividend Paid |
7 cents dividend was paid on 13th October 2017. Total dividend declared was $127 million. |
21.0 cents paid per share on 13th October 2017. Total dividend paid for the year is $73.5 million |
Number of employees |
Approximately 23000 employees in whole group. |
Approximately 6000 employees |
Share price on 18th May 2018: 52 weeks high 52 weeks low |
6.52 AUD 4.77 AUD |
21.29 AUD 16.14 AUD |
Assessment of price movements
Qantas Airways
Date |
Open |
High |
Low |
Close |
Adj Close |
Volume |
20-04-18 |
5.94 |
6.05 |
5.92 |
6.01 |
6.01 |
4839290 |
23-04-18 |
5.98 |
5.98 |
5.9 |
5.9 |
5.9 |
4798735 |
24-04-18 |
5.92 |
5.97 |
5.84 |
5.91 |
5.91 |
7766106 |
26-04-18 |
5.91 |
5.93 |
5.84 |
5.85 |
5.85 |
11264859 |
27-04-18 |
5.81 |
5.82 |
5.655 |
5.69 |
5.69 |
15883332 |
30-04-18 |
5.72 |
5.79 |
5.69 |
5.77 |
5.77 |
6921787 |
01-05-18 |
5.77 |
5.85 |
5.76 |
5.8 |
5.8 |
7314890 |
02-05-18 |
5.97 |
6.29 |
5.97 |
6.27 |
6.27 |
18020493 |
03-05-18 |
6.23 |
6.325 |
6.14 |
6.17 |
6.17 |
15419684 |
04-05-18 |
6.16 |
6.35 |
6.12 |
6.31 |
6.31 |
20778182 |
07-05-18 |
6.39 |
6.45 |
6.36 |
6.43 |
6.43 |
6416615 |
08-05-18 |
6.42 |
6.43 |
6.24 |
6.27 |
6.27 |
6186643 |
09-05-18 |
6.36 |
6.37 |
6.29 |
6.32 |
6.32 |
3978309 |
10-05-18 |
6.26 |
6.31 |
6.12 |
6.17 |
6.17 |
8980366 |
11-05-18 |
6.17 |
6.17 |
6.1 |
6.11 |
6.11 |
8404909 |
14-05-18 |
6.16 |
6.28 |
6.14 |
6.28 |
6.28 |
5854250 |
15-05-18 |
6.25 |
6.31 |
6.15 |
6.29 |
6.29 |
5673751 |
16-05-18 |
6.29 |
6.39 |
6.29 |
6.34 |
6.34 |
4622597 |
17-05-18 |
6.36 |
6.42 |
6.31 |
6.34 |
6.34 |
5194474 |
18-05-18 |
6.35 |
6.37 |
6.3 |
6.33 |
6.33 |
5872961 |
It can be analyzed from above graph that Qantas Airways Ltd has been performing in more appropriate manner to ensure stability in value. Due to same reason continue enhancement in price of same can be accessed i.e. the price have been increased from 6.01 AUD to 6.33 AUD. From the data of table it can be accessed that no major fluctuation have been analyzed in last one year and the same represents the sustainability of company (Hopkin, 2017).
Seek Ltd
Date |
Open |
High |
Low |
Close |
Adj Close |
Volume |
20-04-18 |
19.17 |
19.17 |
18.87 |
19.07 |
19.07 |
491198 |
23-04-18 |
19.09 |
19.14 |
18.85 |
18.89 |
18.89 |
318775 |
24-04-18 |
19 |
19.36 |
18.99 |
19.33 |
19.33 |
447642 |
26-04-18 |
19.44 |
19.5 |
19.205 |
19.34 |
19.34 |
1006444 |
27-04-18 |
19.47 |
19.73 |
19.45 |
19.6 |
19.6 |
608021 |
30-04-18 |
19.65 |
19.65 |
19.38 |
19.43 |
19.43 |
738836 |
01-05-18 |
19.5 |
19.69 |
19.36 |
19.43 |
19.43 |
2237704 |
02-05-18 |
19.54 |
19.99 |
19.52 |
19.89 |
19.89 |
943445 |
03-05-18 |
20.2 |
20.42 |
19.97 |
20.15 |
20.15 |
713413 |
04-05-18 |
20.09 |
20.27 |
19.91 |
20.06 |
20.06 |
366856 |
07-05-18 |
20.26 |
20.75 |
20.02 |
20.36 |
20.36 |
862478 |
08-05-18 |
20.52 |
20.78 |
20.26 |
20.38 |
20.38 |
1091853 |
09-05-18 |
20.67 |
20.71 |
20.55 |
20.67 |
20.67 |
735717 |
10-05-18 |
20.84 |
20.88 |
20.58 |
20.64 |
20.64 |
364954 |
11-05-18 |
20.73 |
20.82 |
20.62 |
20.76 |
20.76 |
437438 |
14-05-18 |
20.8 |
20.84 |
20.7 |
20.8 |
20.8 |
472034 |
15-05-18 |
20.74 |
20.94 |
20.55 |
20.83 |
20.83 |
837662 |
16-05-18 |
20.86 |
20.97 |
20.85 |
20.86 |
20.86 |
808114 |
17-05-18 |
20.84 |
20.9 |
20.605 |
20.75 |
20.75 |
620697 |
18-05-18 |
20.73 |
20.8 |
20.66 |
20.75 |
20.75 |
454374 |
In case of Seek Ltd it could be accessed from above data that company was performing in immense way. But there has been slight fluctuations in decreases in share price of Seek Ltd have been assessed. However, the company has attained the position back till the month of May. The changes in above share price represent that company is not performing in sustainable manner, thus it pertains to higher risk as well as return. As per the report provided by Macquarie Australia Conference presentation it has been assessed that enhancement in profit is not the main objective as it is focusing on capitalizing on substantial marketing opportunities (Brigham and Ehrhardt, 2013). Further revenue of company has been increased to 48% and an enhancement of 36% has been accessed in EBIT.
Calculation relating to purchase of investment |
||||
Particular |
Purchase Date |
Share Price |
No. of Shares |
Amount in $ |
Qantas Airways Share |
20th April 2018 |
6.01 |
831 |
4994.31 |
Seek Ltd Share |
20th April 2018 |
18.96 |
263 |
4986.48 |
Total |
9980.79 |
|||
Calculation relating to sale of investment |
||||
Particular |
Sale Date |
Share Price |
No. of Shares |
Amount in $ |
Qantas Airways Share |
18 th May 2018 |
6.33 |
831 |
5276.85 |
Seek Ltd Share |
18th May 2018 |
20.75 |
263 |
5462.51 |
Total |
10739.36 |
|||
Calculation relating to profit or loss |
||||
Particular |
Amount in $ |
|||
Total amount invested on purchase of share of both the companies |
9980.79 |
|||
Total amount received on sale of shares of both the companies |
10739.36 |
|||
Dividend received |
0 |
|||
Profit / (Loss) |
758.57 |
It is recommended in order to take appropriate investment decision, it is necessary that historical data as well the recent analysis provided by various economists should be considered. As in present case even though financial performance of Seek Ltd. is more appropriate in comparison to Qantas Ltd; but the fact cannot be denied that more fluctuation in share price have been assessed in case of same. Thus, in case investor is ready to bear higher risk in order to attain higher return Qantas Ltd. will be preferred over Seek Ltd. Further in case substantial return will average risk is the choice of investor than Qantas Ltd can be chosen.
Products and Services
($ millions)
Qantas Airways |
Seek Ltd |
|
Revenue / Sales |
13857 |
1053.2 |
Interest Expense |
235 |
29.3 |
EBIT |
1181+235 = 1416 |
437.3+29.3 = 466.6 |
Net Profit Before Tax |
1181 |
437.3 |
Net Profit After Tax |
853 |
362.0 |
Current Assets |
3119 |
841.9 |
Total Assets |
17221 |
3683 |
Current Liabilities |
7095 |
550 |
Total Liabilities |
13681 |
1643.1 |
Total Equity |
3540 |
2039.9 |
Ratio Analysis can be referred as a methodology of assessing financial statement in order to ascertain quick indication relating to organization financial performance in main areas. The ratios are bifurcated in following categories:
- Short term Solvency Ratio
- Asset Management Ratio
- Market Valuation Ratio
- Profitability Ratio
Ratio analysis is significantly dependent on the availability of accounting information relating to the organization. Further the same are being applied in order to compare the performance of two or more organization. In present case same is being done in order to compare the performance of Qantas Airways and Seek Ltd. The area on which further assessment is to be done is ascertained by analyst through assessment of ratio analysis.
($ millions)
Liquidity Ratios |
Qantas Airways |
Seek Ltd |
Working Capital Ratio |
3119/7095 |
841.9/550.0 |
(Current Assets/ Current Liabilities) |
0.439605356 |
1.53 |
Average days sales uncollected |
784/16057*365 |
111.7/1053.2 |
(Accounts Receivable/ Total revenue*365) |
17.82 |
0.11 |
Inventory turnover |
16057/(336+351/2)) |
0.00 |
(Total Revenue/ Average Inventory) |
31.39 |
0.00 |
Average days inventory in hand |
(336+351/2)/16057*365 |
|
(Average Inventory/ Total revenue) *365 |
11.62717 |
0.00 |
Cash Ratio |
1775/7095 |
652/550 |
(Cash / Current Liabilities) |
0.25017618 |
1.19 |
Days of working capital |
(3119-7095)/(16057/365) |
(841.9-550)/(1053.2/365) |
((Current Assets- Current Liabilities)/ (sales /365)) |
-90.38 |
101.16 |
Liquidity ratio assesses the capability of an organization to pay off its current as well as long term liabilities when they become due. The ratio specifies the efficiency of company to convert other assets into cash in order to pay off its liabilities and other current obligation (Heizer, 2016). Cash ratio is believed to be the most significant ratio as it evaluates the ability of company to pay off its short term liabilities with cash and cash equivalents. In present case it can be assessed that Seek Ltd is prominent in managing payment of current liabilities as the same is having comparatively higher cash ratio. Working capital ratio is also referred as current ratio and it evaluates the capability of an organization to pay off its current liabilities with current assets. The faster the assets are converted into cash the more the company will be efficient in paying off its debt (Grant, 2016). In present case it can be assessed that Seek Ltd is efficient in same as it has higher ratio in comparison to Qantas Airways. Overall in all the above liquidity ratio, it can be accessed that they are higher in case of Seek Ltd, the same represents that company is more efficient comparatively in paying off its current liabilities with current assets.
($ millions)
Profitability Ratios |
Qantas |
Seek |
Profit Margin |
853/16057 |
362.0/(1053.2 +177.3) |
(Profit / Total revenue) |
0.053123248 |
0.29 |
Asset Turnover Ratio |
16057/17221 |
(1053.2+177.3)/3683 |
(Total Revenue / Total Assets) |
0.932408106 |
0.33 |
Return on asset |
853/17221 |
362.0/3683 |
(Profit / Total Assets) |
0.049532547 |
0.10 |
Return on Capital Employed |
(1181+235)/(17221-7095) |
(437.3+29.3)/(3683-550) |
(EBIT / (Total assets – Current Liabilities)) |
0.14 |
0.15 |
Return on Sales |
853/(13857+808) |
362.0/1053.2 |
(Profit / Total Sales) |
0.06 |
0.34 |
Return on equity |
853/3540 |
362.0/2039.9 |
(Profit / Total Equity) |
0.240960452 |
0.18 |
Profitability ratios reflect company’s overall effectiveness and performance. There are two types of profitability ratios: first are margins and second are returns. Ratios which demonstrate margins symbolize capability of firm towards transformation of sales dollars in profits on different points of measurement (Jones, 2014). In the same way ratios which reflects returns signifies capability of firm to access overall competence of firm into creating returns in favor of their investors. Profit margin ration assess the percentage of profit generated from certain level of sales. Further, it also indicates the efficiency of company in managing its expenses relating to sales. The higher the ratio, the more the ratio is preferable. The same can be done by company through generating more sales and lowering the expenses. It can be accessed from above analysis that Qantas Airways is able to maintain the same in more appropriate manner in comparison to Seek Ltd. Return on asset ratio evaluates the net income produced by total asset through comparing the net income with its average total assets (McKinney, 2015). As the main motive of company assets is to generate profits, thus the company as well as investor assess that whether the investment in assets have turned into profits or not. It can be analyzed form above assessment that Seek Ltd has appropriately converted its assets into profits. Overall Seek Ltd has attained higher ratios in comparison to Qantas Airways Ltd, but Qantas Airways is having higher return of equity comparatively. The same might significantly affect the decision of investor.
Chief Executive Officer
($ millions)
Stability Ratios |
Qantas |
Seek |
13681/3540 |
1643.1/2039.9 |
|
Debt to Equity Ratio |
3.86 |
0.81 |
(Debt / Equity) |
||
(1181+235)/ 235 |
||
Interest Coverage |
6.03 |
(437.3+29.3)/29.3 |
(EBIT/ Interest Expenses) |
15.92 |
|
Net Cash Transaction Period |
(2067-1775)/2704*12 |
((930.2+37.8 -652)/2704)*12 |
(Net debt / Cash Flow from operating activities)*12 |
1.30 |
13.52 |
Net Debt = Total borrowing – Cash & Cash Equivalent |
||
Debt to Market Cap Proportion |
((2067-1775)/(1853*6.35))*100 |
((930.2+37.8 -652)/(20.77*3476.30))*100 |
(Net Debt)/ Market Capitalization *100 |
2.48 |
0.48 |
Stability evaluate examine how much debt a firm is able to sustain and whether debt and equity are stable or not. It is believed as long term counter part of liquidity. Further financial stability of an organization is necessarily to be ascertained in order to assess the step to be taken relating to investment in that company. Debt to Equity ratio assesses the proportion of debt which is being held by company in comparison to its equity (Petty et al. 2015). Increase in debt to equity ratio represent that company is accomplishing its operations through assistance of finance and which is not a positive variant from point of view of investor decision. In present case it could be assessed from above figures that Qantas Airways is significantly dependent on finance in order to accomplish its operations. As the ratio is higher than 2.0 which is believed as risk for investor, thus the same should be considered while taking decision relating to same. Interest coverage ratio represents the times company operating profits covers the interest expense relating to borrowing (Said, 2016). The higher the ratio, the more assurance relating to same is attained. In present case as Seek Ltd is having higher ratio which could provide relief to the investors that even though the company has been financed from outside sources in significant manner it is performing well, hence they should not be worried about their investment.
Assessment of price of shares is one of the significant variant which is being analyzed by the investors prior to investing in any organization. The above study depicts that the higher the fluctuation exists in share price movements the higher the percentile of risk is related to that organization. Further, it can be depicted from the assessment of ratio analysis assessment that Seek Ltd is comparatively efficient in managing liquidity as it has higher liquidity ratio in comparison to Qantas Ltd. Further, as Seek Ltd is having lower debt to equity ratio is could be asserted that it is able to manage funds for its operations through in-house management only which represent the efficiency of an organization.
References
Hopkin, P., 2017. Fundamentals of risk management: understanding, evaluating and implementing effective risk management. Kogan Page Publishers.
Brigham, E.F. & Ehrhardt, M.C, 2013, Financial management: Theory & practice. Cengage Learning.
Grant, R. M. 2016, Contemporary strategy analysis: Text and cases edition. John Wiley & Sons.
Heizer, J. 2016, Operations Management, 11/e. Pearson Education India.
Jones, M., 2014, Sustainable event management: A practical guide. Routledge.
McKinney, J.B., 2015, Effective financial management in public and nonprofit agencies. ABC-CLIO.
Petty, J.W., Titman, S., Keown, and et.al. 2015. Financial management: Principles and applications. Pearson Higher Education AU.
Said, H.A., 2016. Using Different Probability Distributions for Managerial Accounting Technique: The Cost-Volume-Profit Analysis. Journal of Business and Accounting, 9(1), p.3.
Annual Report of Seek Ltd. 2017. (Online). Available through <https://member.afraccess.com/media?id=CMN://3A481116&filename=20171030/SEK_01914393.pdf>. [Accessed on 19th May 2018]
Annual Report of Qantas Airways. 2017. (Online). Available through <https://investor.qantas.com/FormBuilder/_Resource/_module/doLLG5ufYkCyEPjF1tpgyw/file/annual-reports/2017AnnualReport.pdf>. [Accessed on 19th May 2018]