Auditable Categories and Metrics
Audit Plan
The Project Governance Report is a vital communication tool that is used as the basis for ensuring that the project board and other major project stakeholders are provided with timely, relevant and reliable project information. As a consequence of this report a framework is provided where by issue can be reported and decisions made in a transparently accountable manner.Kerzner (2013) states (p. 21) that governance relates to decisions that define expectations, accountability, responsibility, the granting of power, or verification of performance.
Governance relates to consistent management, cohesive policies, and processes and decisions-making rights for a given area of responsibility. Governance enables efficient and effective decision-making to take place.The PMBOK (2013) section 2.2.2 discusses project governance and advises that it is a framework that provides the project manager and team with structure, processes, decision-making models and tools for managing the project, while supporting and controlling the project for successful delivery.
The report is based on the contents of Directing plus Managing Successful Projects with PRINCE2 (2009), A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK Guide) 5th Edition (2013) and Kerzner Project Management: A Systems Approach to Planning, Scheduling and Controlling (2013).Please complete the report for the case study (Nocturnal Dialysis Conversion Project) provided within the Assessments section in the Moodle.
1. Overall Project Responsibility The responsibility for this project lies with the project manager as he is given the responsibility of managing the entire project. However, all the other stakeholders like supervisor, quality analyst, building contractor and others also have the responsibility to ensure all the duties are fulfilled and all deliverables have been achieved so that the project is completed successfully.The roles of the stakeholders are shown in the following table. The executive management board will monitor the entire project on an overall and will approve certain change requests and management decisions.
2. Roles, Responsibilities and Performance Criteria The roles, responsibilities and performance criteria for this project consist of the duties of the stakeholders that they need to fulfil for the requirements of the project. The performances of the stakeholders will be judged on the basis of the quality and quantity of work they produced during the course of the project. The quality of the stakeholders’ work will decided on the basis of the quality of outcome of the project.
- The project manager will plan, manage and govern the project.
- The sponsor will provide funds for the project.
- The suppliers will provide resources for the project.
- The quality analyst will analyse and audit the quality of the project.
3. Governance Arrangements The governance arrangements for this project consist of monitoring of the project activities of the building contractor. The project manager will specifically appoint the quality analyst and the project supervisor who will govern the project and report back to the project manager. Based on the reports, the project manager will deploy changes that will be beneficial for the project.
1. Relationship to the Portfolio The Relationship to the Portfolio for this project is prepared by using the business strategies of the organization as the basic requirement that needs to be fulfilled during the course of the project. The project portfolio will be created based on the requirements that align towards the preferred business strategy of the organization.
4.Termination / Closure Plan
The roles of relevant stakeholders for the project are shown in the following table.
Auditable Category |
WBS ID and Item Description |
Applicable metrics |
||
1. |
Performance / Progress |
1.1 |
Partial demolition of the existing building |
Area of the building |
1.2 |
Restructuring the dialysis unit |
Nocturnal unit requirements |
||
1.3 |
Upgrade of building to BCA Class 9A |
Class 9A building standards |
||
2. |
Compliance |
2.1 |
Compliance with fire safety |
Fire safety requirements |
2.2 |
Compliance with nocturnal dialysis unit requirements |
Nocturnal unit requirements |
||
2.3 |
Compliance with Class 9A building standards |
Class 9A building standards |
||
3. |
Quality |
3.1 |
Proper quality of building materials |
Building standards |
3.2 |
Good quality of technical equipments |
Medical standards |
||
3.3 |
Good quality of implementation for the nocturnal unit |
Requirements of the unit |
||
4. |
Change / Exit |
4.1 |
Additional equipments for nocturnal unit |
Nocturnal support requirements |
4.2 |
Additional room and space for the nocturnal unit |
Space requirements |
||
4.3 |
Renovation of the dialysis unit |
Upgrade requirements |
||
5. |
Risk |
5.1 |
Additional damage to the hospital building |
Area to be demolished |
5.2 |
Disruption of services to other units of the building |
Specific to dialysis unit |
||
5.3 |
Unavailability of technical equipments for the dialysis unit |
Medical standards requirements |
||
6. |
Best Practices / Lessons to be Learned |
6.1 |
Requirements for Class 9A building |
Understanding the requirements of Class 9A building |
6.2 |
Following fire and safety guidelines |
Standard guidelines for safety |
||
6.3 |
Upgradation of a particular part of a building |
Upgradation process |
||
Audit Category |
Item |
When will it be conducted? |
Who will conduct? |
Purpose (discovery or decision-making)? |
Performance / Progress |
Partial demolition of the existing building |
10th March 2018 |
Building Contractor |
For renovation and addition of space |
Restructuring the dialysis unit |
25th March 2018 |
Medical Unit Contractor |
For developing the nocturnal unit |
|
Upgrade of building to BCA Class 9A |
5th April 2018 |
Building Contractor |
For upgrading the existing building standard |
|
Compliance |
Compliance with fire safety |
5th March 2018 |
Building Contractor |
To protect the building against fire hazards |
Compliance with nocturnal dialysis unit requirements |
5th March 2018 |
Medical unit contractor |
To develop the building for nocturnal unit |
|
Compliance with Class 9A building standards |
20th March 2018 |
Building contractor |
To upgrade the standard of the building |
|
Quality |
Proper quality of building materials |
5th March 2018 |
Procurement manager |
To ensure the building does not get damaged by external agents |
Good quality of technical equipments |
8th March 2018 |
Procurement manager |
To meet current medical standards |
|
Good quality of implementation for the nocturnal unit |
15th March 2018 |
Quality analyst |
To meet requirements of the nocturnal unit |
|
Change / Exit |
Additional equipments for nocturnal unit |
20th March 2018 |
Project Manager |
To meet requirements of the nocturnal unit |
Additional room and space for the nocturnal unit |
25th March 2018 |
Project Manager |
To meet requirements of the nocturnal unit |
|
Renovation of the dialysis unit |
5th April 2018 |
Project Manager |
For upgrading the current system |
|
Risk |
Additional damage to the hospital building |
20th March 2018 |
Building Contractor |
Avoiding accidental damage |
Disruption of services to other units of the building |
20th March 2018 |
Supervisor |
Avoiding disturbing other units and wards |
|
Unavailability of technical equipments for the dialysis unit |
25th March 2018 |
Procurement Manager |
Meeting current medical standards |
|
Best Practices / Lessons to be Learned |
Requirements for Class 9A building |
10th April 2018 |
Project Manager |
Learning about various building standards and categories |
Following fire and safety guidelines |
10th April 2018 |
Project Manager |
Learning about safety standards of a building |
|
Upgradation of a particular part of a building |
10th April 2018 |
Project Manager |
Learning about project requirements |
|
Controllable Category |
Item & Explanation |
PMBOK Knowledge Area |
||
Input |
Tool & Technique |
Output |
||
1. Deliverable |
1.1 Renovation of Building |
Demolition |
Bulldozer |
Newly renovated unit |
The dialysis unit will be renovated as per the requirements of the project. |
||||
1.2 Installation of new equipments |
Budget |
Negotiation |
New Dialysis Equipments |
|
The new equipments will be installed for the nocturnal unit. |
||||
1.3 Additional space for new unit |
Original Unit |
Construction |
New Unit, Increased area of existing unit |
|
The unit space will be increased to accommodate more research and treatment area. |
||||
2. Configuration |
2.1 Newly developed nocturnal dialysis unit |
Demolition |
Bulldozer |
Newly renovated unit |
The new nocturnal unit will be developed side by side with the old unit. |
||||
2.2 New dialysis equipments |
Old Equipments |
Procurement |
New Equipments |
|
New equipments will match the current medical standards. |
||||
3. Status Accounts |
3.1 Demolition report |
Demolition Status |
Documentation |
Status Account 1 |
A part of the unit will be temporarily demolished. |
||||
3.2 Construction report |
Construction Status |
Documentation |
Status Account 2 |
|
The construction process will be documented. |
||||
3.3 Installation report |
Installation Status |
Documentation |
Status Account 3 |
|
The installation process will be documented. |
||||
4. Logs |
4.1 Project log |
Project Progress |
Documentation |
Progress Report |
Project progress should be logged to keep track. |
||||
4.2 Resource log |
Resources Used |
Documentation |
Resources Report |
|
There should be log for keeping tabs on the resources used in the project. |
||||
4.3 Expense log |
Monetary Expenses |
Documentation |
Expenditure Report |
|
There should be log for keeping tabs on the budget used in the project. |
||||
5. Issues |
5.1 Construction issues |
Issues Log |
Documentation |
Solutions to Issues |
Monitor issues to address using suitable solutions. |
||||
5.2 Internal issues |
Issues Log |
Documentation |
Solutions to Issues |
|
Monitor issues to address using suitable solutions. |
||||
5.3 Technical issues |
Issues Log |
Documentation |
Solutions to Issues |
|
Monitor issues to address using suitable solutions. |
||||
6. Procurements |
6.1 Building materials |
Budget |
Documentation |
Materials |
Building materials are to be procured for increasing the unit area. |
||||
6.2 Building machineries |
Budget |
Documentation |
Machineries on Rent |
|
Building machineries will be required for demolition and reconstruction. |
||||
6.3 Dialysis equipments |
Budget |
Documentation |
Equipments |
|
New dialysis equipments will be used in the nocturnal unit. |
||||
Name |
Role |
Key Quality Responsibility |
||
PLEASE FILL |
Project Manager |
Plans and manages entire project |
||
PLEASE FILL |
Sponsor |
Analyzes cost benefit from the project |
||
PLEASE FILL |
Vendor |
Provides resources for the project |
||
PLEASE FILL |
Project Contractor |
Executes the project |
||
PLEASE FILL |
Quality Analyst |
Monitors the quality of the project |
||
Deliverables |
Acceptance Criteria |
|||
Additional Space for Existing Dialysis Unit |
Room size doubled |
|||
New Equipments for Dialysis |
Equipments of Current Medical Standards |
|||
New Room for Nocturnal Unit |
Similar room as the previous one with nocturnal support |
|||
Renovation of the Dialysis Unit |
Room damages repaired |
1. Overall Project Responsibility
The responsibility for this project lies with the project manager as he is given the responsibility of managing the entire project. However, all the other stakeholders like supervisor, quality analyst, building contractor and others also have the responsibility to ensure all the duties are fulfilled and all deliverables have been achieved so that the project is completed successfully.
The roles of the stakeholders are shown in the following table. The executive management board will monitor the entire project on an overall and will approve certain change requests and management decisions.
2. Roles, Responsibilities and Performance Criteria The roles, responsibilities and performance criteria for this project consist of the duties of the stakeholders that they need to fulfil for the requirements of the project. The performances of the stakeholders will be judged on the basis of the quality and quantity of work they produced during the course of the project. The quality of the stakeholders’ work will decided on the basis of the quality of outcome of the project.
- The project manager will plan, manage and govern the project.
- The sponsor will provide funds for the project.
- The suppliers will provide resources for the project.
- The quality analyst will analyse and audit the quality of the project.
3. Governance Arrangements The governance arrangements for this project consist of monitoring of the project activities of the building contractor. The project manager will specifically appoint the quality analyst and the project supervisor who will govern the project and report back to the project manager. Based on the reports, the project manager will deploy changes that will be beneficial for the project. 5. Relationship to the Portfolio The Relationship to the Portfolio for this project is prepared by using the business strategies of the organization as the basic requirement that needs to be fulfilled during the course of the project. The project portfolio will be created based on the requirements that align towards the preferred business strategy of the organization.
1. Authorisation Points The authorisation points for this project are based on the decisions taken by the project manager but will be specifically applied to certain project attributes like:
- Budget
- Schedule
- Contract Tender
- Additional fund requests
- Project Site
- Building Standards
- Resources Required
- Completion of Repair
- Additional Space for Dialysis Unit
- New Nocturnal Unit
- Repair of Existing Unit
All these must be first authorized by the project manager before they are processed further.Decision making process: –
- Project Progress
- Compliance with Standards
- Audit of Project Quality
- Change Management
- Risk Assessment
- Reflection on Project
2. Delegation The delegation arrangements for this project are the responsibilities of the human resources manager and the delegation process will the done on the basis of skills and experience. The duties will first be divided and then the human resources manager will appoint stakeholders to their duties after assessing their skills and experience in the chosen role.The delegation for this project is as follows. 3. Information Validity
The information regarding the project will be documented in business case and the validity of information will be verified by:
- Project budget and expenses
- Project time period
- Cost and other benefits
- Business strategy options
- Major risks
- Future scope
- Advantages of the project
Scrutiny
The scrutiny arrangements for this project are done on the basis of the requirements of the project. Generally, the scrutiny process is done at the end of the project by the project manager but in many projects including this one, there will be a continuous scrutiny process to be undertaken by the supervisor and report to the project manager. The initial scrutiny will be done by the project manager whereas the final scrutiny will be performed by the management board who will then business decisions accordingly.
Status Reporting
- The status reporting arrangements for this project are based on written reports and will be carried out by the project stakeholders.
- Each of the stakeholders will create a project log and at the end of each week, the weekly project log will be collected together and the status of the project will be reported to the project manager by sending the updated project log.
- There will also be an audit report that will be made in order to review the quality of the project on a regular basis.
- Further, there are evm and control reports that are used to monitor project progress, meeting of deliverables and others.
Improvement
- The improvement arrangements for this project are based on certain standards set by the project manager before the initiation of the project.
- The entire project can be further improved if the project manager governs the project regularly and inject new ideas for enhancement of the project.
- The stakeholders should ensure updating the project manager using daily project progress reports so that he is able to govern the project as well as execute change management.
Stakeholder Engagement
The stakeholder engagement arrangements for this project are to be done by the human resources manager but the stakeholder requirement perquisites will be set by the project manager. The stakeholders of the project will be separately added after they are tested for their skills and experiences in their roles.
The stakeholder engagement is shown as follows.
Role |
Key Quality Responsibility |
|
Project Manager |
Reviews and validates project outcome |
|
Sponsor |
Reviews financial expenses in the project |
|
Vendor |
Reviews resources provided for the project |
|
Project Contractor |
Hands over the project to the project manager |
|
Quality Analyst |
Reviews quality of project outcome |
|
Name |
Role |
Key Quality Responsibility |
PLEASE FILL |
Project Manager |
Plans and manages entire project |
PLEASE FILL |
Sponsor |
Analyzes cost benefit from the project |
PLEASE FILL |
Vendor |
Provides resources for the project |
PLEASE FILL |
Project Contractor |
Executes the project |
PLEASE FILL |
Quality Analyst |
Monitors the quality of the project |
Deliverables |
Acceptance Criteria |
|
Additional Space for Existing Dialysis Unit |
Room size doubled |
|
New Equipments for Dialysis |
Equipments of Current Medical Standards |
|
New Room for Nocturnal Unit |
Similar room as the previous one with nocturnal support |
|
Renovation of the Dialysis Unit |
Room damages repaired |
|
Designation |
Role |
|
Project Manager |
Planning of project, allocation of duties |
|
Procurement Manager |
Procurement of necessary resources |
|
Architect |
Design plan for nocturnal unit |
|
Civil Engineer |
Design framework for the demolition and construction |
|
Contractor |
Execute the demolition and construction process |
Name |
Role |
Key Quality Responsibility |
PLEASE FILL |
Project Manager |
Plans and manages entire project |
PLEASE FILL |
Sponsor |
Analyzes cost benefit from the project |
PLEASE FILL |
Vendor |
Provides resources for the project |
PLEASE FILL |
Project Contractor |
Executes the project |
PLEASE FILL |
Quality Analyst |
Monitors the quality of the project |
Schwalbe, K. (2015). Information technology project management. Cengage Learning.Walker, A. (2015).
Project management in construction. John Wiley & Sons.